Jennifer Pelosi
Jun 04, 2026"Haven't been here in awhile, food and drinks were awesome. Service was top notch tonight our server Bernadette was a pro. Had clams casino, baked rigatoni, rigatoni with crumbled sauage and shrimp. Expresso martini."
New York, United States
Discover traditional Italian dishes, live music weekends, and a cozy atmosphere at Amici Restaurant in Mt Sinai, NY. Dine-in, takeout, or delivery options available.
4.4 / 5
Guest rating
715
Reviews
Italian Restaurant
Cuisine
New York
City
$30–50
Price level
Closes at 10:00 PM
Amici Restaurant offers a relaxed setting with a wide selection of traditional Italian cuisine. Located on NY-25A in Mt Sinai, this local spot features a menu ranging from classic pasta dishes to seasonal specials, accompanied by a well-curated wine and cocktail list.
The restaurant provides a casual and lively atmosphere with amenities including live weekend music, a cozy fireplace, and both indoor and outdoor seating. The dining experience suits solo diners, families, and groups, making it a versatile destination for lunch and dinner.
Visitors can choose from dine-in, takeout, catering, and no-contact delivery services, accommodating a variety of dining preferences. Accessibility is thoughtfully addressed with wheelchair-friendly entrances, seating, restrooms, and parking.
Popular dishes feature a mix of hearty and fresh options such as Fried Calamari, Chicken Francese, and Penne Alla Vodka, complemented by vegetarian and healthy choices. Reservations are advised, especially for dinner.
Grouped by category — each group lists what's available and what isn't at Amici Restaurant.
When Amici Restaurant is open during the week.
Closes at 10:00 PM
Central New York, with cafes, shops, and other restaurants within easy walking distance.
What recent guests say after dining at Amici Restaurant.
Based on 715 guest reviews
Jennifer Pelosi
Jun 04, 2026"Haven't been here in awhile, food and drinks were awesome. Service was top notch tonight our server Bernadette was a pro. Had clams casino, baked rigatoni, rigatoni with crumbled sauage and shrimp. Expresso martini."
Ingris Agustin
May 26, 2026"Had an amazing dinner at this restaurant ! My friend and I stopped by after his shift at work on a Saturday night and although they were packed they seated us right away. We happened to stop by during restaurant week and ordered from the pre fixed menu apps, entree and dessert. We ordered the stuffed medallion chicken and North Atlantic salmon with a lobster risotto for the entree and to say it was filling and delicious is an understatement. We even had leftovers to take home! After reviewing the regular prices I can say it’s worth the price with or without the pre fixed menu. The holiday cocktails like the rainbow cookie martini and apple cider sangria were amazing as well. We sat in the dining section but there was also a bar section with live music that night. Overall amazing experience, highly recommend !"
Kevin
May 25, 2026"This place was very nice. The price was good and the food was good as well. Portion size is good for the price. Service here is great and everyone is super friendly!!! Vodka sauce was the best i ever had!! Fried calamari had a surprise couple of fried pickels and fried pickled chili pepers!! Everything was amazing!!"
Ralph Courter
May 16, 2026"We sat outside on a Saturday afternoon. Was empty when we got there. But was filling up when we left around 6:30. Band was getting ready to play. 4 of us had a relaxing meal with good food and friendly service."
HDHD
Mar 25, 2026"Second time in as many weeks, and both times were great. Very attentive service, the menu/food has a great variety, fresh, good sized portions, and delicious. Live music in the bar area which has a dining section, dimly lit and cozy, with beautiful fireplace in winter, and the dining rooms are large with nice white table covers, also a huge fireplace. Looks and feels like a mountain lodge with an Italian twist. Great for date nights or family dinners."
Jenn L
Mar 10, 2026"We had an absolutely delicious meal tonight at Amici's. Our server, Ashley, was fantastic. We will definitely be back!"
Ryan M
Mar 04, 2026"Amici was awesome. Went here with my wife for dinner. Atmosphere was nice and rustic, great cozy place to eat. Service was extremely quick and we did not even have to ask for a thing. Food was beyond fresh and delicious, best penne alla vodka I’ve ever had. The chicken was amazing and the fried calamari was great. Everything was cooked perfectly and everyone was very nice. Will definitely be going back."
Common questions about visiting Amici Restaurant.
Amici specializes in traditional Italian dishes with a diverse menu including pasta, seafood, small plates, and seasonal specials.
Reservations are accepted and recommended, especially for dinner service to help ensure seating availability.
Yes, there is outdoor seating available for guests who prefer dining al fresco when weather permits.
The restaurant has a wheelchair-accessible entrance, parking, restrooms, and seating to accommodate guests with mobility requirements.
Options include dine-in, takeout, no-contact delivery, and catering services to suit different dining preferences.
The menu includes vegetarian dishes along with healthy options to accommodate various dietary preferences.
Free parking is offered through a lot and street parking, along with some paid parking options nearby.
Amici is family-friendly and provides amenities such as a kids' menu and high chairs suitable for younger guests.
Keep your listing accurate by updating your address, opening hours, menu, photos, and contact details. Reach more diners searching for Italian Restaurant in New York on Locallya.